Stoner's Pizza Joint

Jessica G. 6 months ago

Horrible. I ordered from DoorDash sadly. Wish I wouldn’t have. The photos make it look fantastic and are why I chose this place. But what I received was disgusting. Three of my 4 boxes had some sort of butter sauce spilled open all over the boxes dripping into the lower boxes and pizzas (containers open and spilled in boxes) and the pizzas themselves make chain stores like dominos and little Caesar’s look like high end. This is horrible. I cannot believe how much they charge for this let alone receiving damaged pizza.

Boz Rocks a year ago

We decided to try a new pizzeria tonight. So we chose Stoner's. We placed our order when we arrived. We ordered the Touchdown, which is 2 large specialty pizzas for $35.99. The wait for them was long, we waited about 45 minutes. We placed the order at 9:10 and they brought it out at about 9:55. I think we get specialty pizzas like that in about 25 minutes at most places. But the pizzas were very good. The crust is sweet. I think it took long because there were only 2 people there. And I think only 1 was officially working. I saw some basic employment instructions on the whiteboard in the back office. Someone is taking leadership seriously, and I commend them for that. Some places in Fayetteville lack basic customer service. While it's sad these basic things need to be written down (like "be nice to your coworkers") I'm glad someone understands a way to correct the issues and is leading this group to do better and be better. As far as customer service goes, the young lady who took our order was friendly and helpful. We enjoyed our visit.

Rendy Donaldson Edited a year ago

The young lady that was at the register was extremely rude. The food was as good as it looks. I ordered 1 Large pizza, 1 Large calzone, and 3 chocolate chip cookies. The calzone was raw on the inside. The crust to the pizza was very hard to chew. The cookies were okay. I would not recommend any food to anyone. My husband and I have tried their food a lot and each time the calzone is under cooked. Try at your own risk. ***UPDATE They changed the person behind the register!! The woman that was there today was very courteous, quick, and efficient. Apparently their power had just turned back on when I placed my order. She made our food without missing a beat and provided wonderful customer service. The food looked and tasted much better than last time. We bought a small buffalo chicken pizza and a large calzone.

Adam Jay Edited a year ago

Had HIGH hopes for Stoners Pizza. Upon arrival no communication or greeting with customer maybe they were rolling up some Great Pizza. Almost had to acknowledge myself - Hello!!! Today I ordered a simple Hand Tossed sausage pizza it took about 10 minutes to receive order. I asked if it came with any sauces like I've seen in other posts & she said Yes! but we don't have any sauces today. Already I'm starting to think if this was a great choice for a lunch review considering that you won't get the whole experience. Overall nothing special. The cheese was probably the best part. The dough looked great but was thin as cardboard on the bottom & it had 0 flavor (still had a raw dough taste after baking) & the crust was tough as leather 😬 *Unable to eat or break" No crisp at all. The toppings & cheese were the savior. This was the worst best looking pizza I ever had from anywhere. Having to drive past multiple great pizza chains and about 10 miles out the way to get here I will probably never return.

Natalie Underwood Edited a year ago

Me and my boyfriend and I had a great experience here. The food was very good and so was the customer service and the atmosphere. We ordered a pepperoni pizza with onions in the really big size and in NY thin style pizza, and we also ordered the strawberry stromboli. which was very delicious and the full size almost greek salad which was very good. And Q, who took our order and made our order was very polite and she made our experience even better. I would definitely recommend this place over any other pizza place in Fayetteville.